Experts Say Recent ‘Alien’ Mummy Study Was Deeply Flawed and Unethical

Earlier this yr , scientists from Stanford University concluded that a strange underframe screw as the Atacama Mummy belonged to a human girl whose strong-arm miscreation were the final result of several severe genetic sport . A team of outside expert is now questioning these finding , and accusing the scientists of breaching standard research moral principle .

The Atacama Mummy , or Ata as it ’s known , was describe 15 year ago in a abandoned Chilean Ithiel Town in the Atacama Desert . The specimen is only about six in long , it ’s neglect a pair of costa , and it has a highly deformed head and face . Naturally , some UFOlogists figured the mummy was of extraterrestrial descent , prompting its coming into court ina unretentive documentary .

Scientific enquiry suggest otherwise . A 2013 paper led by Garry Nolan , an immunologist at Stanford University , conclude that Ata was human , and that the skeleton ’s osseous tissue give the mental picture that it was between the age of six and eight years old when it died , though such an age would have been unsufferable . Earlier this year , Nolan , along with fellow worker Atul Butte , theater director of the Institute for Computational Health Sciences at the University of California - San Francisco , conducted a follow - up depth psychology . This newspaper , release in the science journalGenome Research , presented evidence showing thata serial of genetical mutations were creditworthy for the foreign featuresseen in the distorted specimen . The investigator conclude that Ata was a missy of Chilean descent who was a develop fetus at the time of her decease , and that she suffer from a rare os - aging disorder .

Argentina’s President Javier Milei (left) and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., holding a chainsaw in a photo posted to Kennedy’s X account on May 27. 2025.

Within days of the study being put out , a contestation emerged . The Chilean National Monuments Council launched an investigation , order the mummy ’s corpse may have been acquired through illegal smuggling and grave robbing , and that the inquiry was altogether inappropriate . Some Chilean scientists become so far as to say that Genome Research paper should be draw back .

Now , some four calendar month after the paper was write , Nolan and Butte are facing another tone-beginning , this time from an external team of expert led by Sian Halcrow from the University of Otago , New Zealand . Theirnew paper , release today in the International Journal of Paleopathology , claims that Nolan ’s research is instinct with errors and misinterpretations , and that a transmitted study in all probability should n’t have been carry in the first position .

The authors of the new newspaper chance “ no evidence ” of the gaunt anomaly described in the Genome Research newspaper . The abnormal characteristics described by Nolan and Butte , the authors say , are reproducible with normal foetal bony ontogeny .

William Duplessie

“ We are expert in developmental human material body and archaeology , and the mummy looks normal for a foetus around 15 - 16 weeks gestation , ” tell Kristina Killgrove , a bioarchaeologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and a Centennial State - author of the new study , in an consultation with Gizmodo . “ To the average mortal , I understand how Ata could look odd , but that ’s because the modal someone does n’t see acquire foetus or ma . ”

The researchers , for example , found no evidence of the osseous tissue abnormality cited in the Genome Research composition , nor any grounds in keep of the assertion that Ata ’s off-white gave the appearing of someone aged six to eight year . The absent 11th and twelfth ribs is normal for a foetus of this age , the researchers say , as these ribs have yet to full form .

As for the misshapen skull , the investigator refer to a figure of possibilities , including a process foretell “ shaping deformation , ” where the skull , owing to oestrus pressure , becomes deformed when swallow up in the priming . More credibly , the researchers say Ata ’s cranial bones were “ altered ” by the mother ’s cervix during delivery in a process known as moulding — a phenomenon sometimes seen in severe preterm fetus . “ The ‘ elongated cranium ’ of Ata is therefore phenotypically normal for a preterm fetus that has been delivered , ” save the researchers in the cogitation .

Starship Test 9

Finally , the researchers found no gaunt evidence of the genetic precondition cited in Nolan ’s most recent paper .

“ Unfortunately , there was no scientific rationale to undertake genomic analyses of Ata because the skeletal frame is normal , the identify inherited mutations are possibly coincidental , and none of the genetic mutations are have intercourse to be powerfully associated with skeletal pathology that would strike the systema skeletale at this young years , ” said Halcrow in a statement .

The flawed nature of the Genome Research subject , the authors argue , highlights the pauperization for interdisciplinary research approaches , which in this subject should ’ve involved expert in osteology , music , archaeology , account , and genetic science . “ A nuanced sympathy of skeletal biological processes and ethnical context is substantive for accurate scientific rendition and for acting as a check on the ethics and legality of such inquiry , ” enunciate Halcrow .

Lilo And Stitch 2025

Bernardo Arriaza , a bioarchaeologist from the University of Tarapacá in Chile and a co - source of the young study , said Nolan and his colleagues should have considered the archaeologic context within which the mummy was regain . It ’s possible that Ata is a fail fetus , and from the very recent past tense . “ This mommy reflects a sad deprivation for a mother in the Atacama Desert , ” he said .

The writer also kvetch that no morality statement or notice of an archaeologic permit was include in the Genome Research paper .

“ Given the fact that the mummified fetus was clearly human , the geneticists did not need to do further testing , ” said Killgrove . “ But more knotty than that was , once they did test and find it was human , they did n’t immediately block and question the forensic or archeologic morals . Whether the fetus mummy was ancient or more late , Chile require permit for this sorting of examination . We think that these geneticists should have involve a specialist in developmental skeletal biological science from the offset as they would not have made rookie mistakes . But we also want to use this as a cautionary tale live on onward — genetic science experts call for to be informed about ancient and modern laws and morality surrounding examination . ”

CMF by Nothing Phone 2 Pro has an Essential Key that’s an AI button

We confirm the need to respect the traditions of other culture in genomic depth psychology . We have antecedently stated that we believe the pinched remains should be returned to the country of stock and , by finding them to be human , this enquiry supports the argumentation that these remains should be repatriated . This inquiry elucidate what has been a very public and sensationalized account for a longsighted time , and it was done out of a desire to fetch some humanity to this treatment and self-worth to the skeleton .

The skeleton in the closet has never been in the possession of either Stanford or UCSF , and we had nothing to do with absent the skeleton from its place of parentage . The DNA and image arrive from remains that were not known to be human when the research began . It does not leave identifiable entropy about a living mortal , as delimitate by Union regulations , and does not characterise as human subjects research , per the Federal Office of Human Research Protections . It has long been know that this skeleton was privately carry in Spain , without any allegations of criminal conduct as to how it was acquired .

Speaking to theNew York Timesback in March , Nolan said he had no reason to trust that the mummy was obtain lawlessly , and that it was n’t obvious they were deal with a human specimen . Subsequently , his squad did n’t require permission from Stanford University to take a skeleton that peradventure belong to to a nonhuman primate .

Photo: Jae C. Hong